JAKARTA (JP): Buoyed by impressive initial results of
its project in Indonesia, the local unit of Monsanto
announced on Wednesday that it is continuing with
controversial transgenic cotton farming in South Sulawesi.
Hans Bijlmer, country director of the St. Louis-based
transgenic-seed giant, said the company was forging ahead
with the project, confident of continued government
support.
"The Minister of Agriculture (Bungaran Saragih),
in a meeting with cotton farmers in Bulukumba and
Bantaeng, promised to extend the license for transgenic
cotton. And I think he will," Bijlmer told The
Jakarta Post after briefing the media on the initial
results of the South Sulawesi cotton project.
The ministry ignored protests in February by some
non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and issued a license
allowing limited release of the genetically modified
cotton known as Bt Cotton or Bollgard, imported from South
Africa, in the province.
The NGOs opposed the commercial application of genetic
technology saying that,despite promises of better yields,
the full impact on human lives and the environment was not
yet known.
PT Monagro Kimia, the Indonesian unit of Monsanto, said
in a statement that yields in its genetically enhanced
cotton plantation reached 1.5 tons to three tons per
hectare, or three times to four times higher than
conventional varieties.
It said commercial planting of the Bollgard cotton was
the first in the tropics, and the average results were
better or matched those achieved by small-holders in South
Africa and China.
Biljmer's optimism came despite South Sulawesi Governor
HZB Palaguna's remarks on Wednesday that the project might
be terminated after the burning of four hectares of
transgenic cotton plantations in Bulukumba regency,
apparently by farmers involved in the project.
Biljmer accused NGOs opposed to transgenic crops as
being behind the incident.
"We suspect that NGOs were behind it. It's like
the demonstrations, they are not spontaneous but
organized," he said, without mentioning any specific
NGO by name.
Monagro Kimia currently manages transgenic-cotton farms
in seven regencies in South Sulawesi: Takalar, Gowa,
Bantaeng, Bulukumba, Bone, Soppeng and Wajo, covering a
total area of 4,363 hectares, involving 6,500 farmers.
The National Consortium for Nature and Forest
Conservation, which is leading a coalition of 72 NGOs
opposing the commercial introduction of transgenic
technology, challenged Bijlmer to prove his accusation.
Executive director Tejo Wahyu Jatmika said the attack
by local farmers reflected their discontent that the
project had not improved their condition.
"It proves that PT Monagro Kimia only gave false
promises," Tejo said.
Monagro fabricated the accusation to divert public
attention from the real problem: the project was a
failure, he said.
Tejo also questioned the Minister of Agriculture's
promise to extend the license on transgenic plantation
before a review.
"The review will not take place until Oct. 8. How
could the minister have given the green light?" he
asked.