I was surprised and disappointed by the article Leuser
Park -a battle unbegun by Donna K. Woodward (June 30).
For a person who served for several years as an
administrative officer in the United States consulate in
Medan, I would have expected an article that offered
constructive criticism -- one based on accurate
information and which reflected sound reasoning. Instead
readers were treated to a litany of anecdotes, false
allegations and old fashioned debating tricks that makes
one wonder what purpose such an article served.
The Leuser Development Program (LDP) aims to create the
conditions for effective conservation of the Leuser
Ecosystem. Serving such a large area of some 25,000 square
kilometers requires good logistics. The
"megavehicles" criticized by Miss Woodward (who,
commendably, uses a bicycle for traveling around Medan)
are a part of this support. They are standard project
Landrovers imported duty free and thus cost about the same
as a Toyota Corolla. The project field offices are
important for the same reason, and contrary to Miss
Woodward's assertions, none of these have ever been closed
down.
For a person claiming to be a "management
consultant" Miss Woodward's failure to properly check
the facts regarding the LDP is disturbing. The suggestion
that most of the money for the project has been spent is
not true -- the real figure is about half. Even with this
outlay, there have been significant results. For instance,
some 400,000 hectares of forest in the Leuser Ecosystem,
that would otherwise have been destroyed and converted
into oil palm plantations and cattle ranches, have been
saved. The 100,000 hectare-Singkil Swamp, which is
currently being gazetted as a wildlife sanctuary, is just
one example of this effort.
While it is true that illegal logging is a major
problem in Leuser, as elsewhere in Indonesia, it is
important to remember that the LDP has no mandate to
enforce the law or to suppress legal activities. While the
LDP has been active in lobbying against illegal logging,
it certainly has never negotiated with the military over
turning a blind eye to illegal logging activities. This
allegation and others concerning supposed collusion are
not only unfounded, but are serious enough for LDP
management to consider pressing legal charges against the
writer.
The task of saving Leuser's forests is indeed a
"mammoth" one. Miss Woodward's remarks merely
stir up doubt and play into the hands of those who would
rather see those forests destroyed.
DENI PURBA
Legal Officer
Leuser Development Program
Medan, North Sumatra